Modern Family: Week 9 in Review

KIP MOONEY: At least they got the “Express” part right.

Tonight’s episode, titled “Christmas Express,” is far too busy to get nearly anything right. In fact, this is the first holiday episode the show hasn’t nailed. The complaints often lobbed at this show tend to focus on the disjointed storylines, and some characters disappearing for episodes at a time to focus on the bigger arcs. But here’s an episode that tries to include literally everyone, and ends up with too little.

The episode begins with everyone hanging out at the pool and realizing this will be the first Christmas where they won’t all be together. Jay, Gloria and Manny are headed south of the border. Mitch and Cam are off to Missouri to see Cam’s handsy mama. And DeDe (Shelley Long, who I would have loved to have seen in at least a cameo) has canceled her trip to take a cruise with her new boyfriend.

So Phil comes up with a bright dumb idea to rush the holiday season into the next four hours, with a big Christmas dinner that night. Everyone gets their assignments:

Phil & Manny: Dinner
Claire & Haley: Presents
Mitch & Alex: Tree
Cam & Jay: Wrapping
Gloria & Luke: Locate the angel tree-topper

On paper, I love these pairings. But they just didn’t work in execution. For one, I can’t buy a smart kid like Manny being scared of getting kidnapped at any moment. Meanwhile, Mitch and Alex were elitist peas in an pod and Gloria and Luke were too dense to be any fun. You gotta have a straight man. But over at Target (hello, product placement!), you can also tell where Haley gets her conniving streak.

Of course everything goes horribly wrong, because you can’t rush Christmas and all that. While I’ve had some complaints about this year, this is the first episode this season I’ve genuinely disliked. The series’ previous low points at least had other storylines I enjoyed. Tonight was almost all bad. Hopefully the writers will recharge over the holiday break and come back with some fresh stories.

BEST LINES (all-Cam edition):
“Who do you think we’re seeing in Missouri? The Oak Ridge Boys?”
– after Claire insinuates present company is the “real” family

“The way you wrap a gift: so much tape. No one can get in. Kinda like…”
– to the typically unemotional Jay

Jay: “You want to hug me, don’t you?”
Cam: “I kinda do.”
Jay: “OK. Four to five seconds.”
Cam: “Forty-five seconds?!”
Jay: “Four to five seconds!”
– after Jay does something unexpectedly jolly

About Kip Mooney

Kip Mooney is a recent graduate of UNT's Mayborn School of Journalism and big-time opponent of going to grad school. Working as a freelance writer in the DFW area, he's always ready to go in-depth with his opinions on film, television, music, religion and the sorry state of politics in America. He continues to work independently, as each of his non-college jobs has resulted in the company experiencing serious financial troubles once he leaves, including Blockbuster and the trashy restaurant D's Country Kitchen. (The lesson here is hire him, but don't let him leave.) His literary heroes include Roger Ebert, Donald Miller and Matt Taibbi. Kip has written for The Dallas Morning News and Pegasus News and served as editor-in-chief for the North Texas Daily, but he is perhaps best known as the inspiration for Christian Lander's well-known blog Stuff White People Like.
This entry was posted in Arts & Culture and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.